| 1 | Sir Vivian Richards | Batsman | 1974-1991 | One of the greatest batsmen in history, led WI to dominance in the ’70s & ’80s |
| 2 | Sir Garfield Sobers | All-rounder | 1954-1974 | Arguably the greatest all-rounder, over 8000 Test runs and 200+ wickets |
| 3 | Brian Lara | Batsman | 1990-2007 | Holds the record for the highest Test score (400*), one of the finest stroke players |
| 4 | Clive Lloyd | All-rounder | 1966-1985 | Led WI to two World Cup titles, a powerful hitter and a key middle-order batsman |
| 5 | Curtly Ambrose | Fast Bowler | 1988-2000 | 405 Test wickets, known for his pace and consistency |
| 6 | Malcolm Marshall | Fast Bowler | 1978-1991 | 376 Test wickets, one of the greatest fast bowlers in cricket history |
| 7 | Sir Andy Roberts | Fast Bowler | 1974-1983 | Pioneering West Indian fast bowler, key figure in WI’s fast-bowling dominance |
| 8 | Richie Richardson | Batsman | 1983-2000 | Over 8000 Test runs, one of WI’s most consistent batsmen |
| 9 | Joel Garner | Fast Bowler | 1977-1987 | Part of the fearsome West Indian fast-bowling quartet, 259 Test wickets |
| 10 | Courtney Walsh | Fast Bowler | 1984-2001 | WI’s leading wicket-taker in Tests, 519 wickets in the format |